The questions for today are focused on vaginal birth after caesarean surgery, VBAC.
This is the second post in the current series
- about midwives who have (or plan to obtain) Medicare provider numbers
- about planned homebirth
- about planned hospital birth
- about vaginal birth after caesarean surgery (VBAC)
- about women who have certain 'risk' factors
- about ...
I have shaded the 'planned homebirth' and 'planned hospital birth' lines as well as the VBAC line, because the place of birth, home or hospital, is a *setting* - not an outcome.
Women often ask independent midwives:
"Will you be my midwife for a HBAC?", or HBA2C (where H=home, and 2=2, and where, because it's at H, it's obviously V)
(and yes, we use abbreviations freely!)
The only truthful answer is "I have no idea, because it's impossible for me to know where your baby will be born!"
But, what is implied in the question "Will you be my midwife for a HBAC"? is,
- are you willing and able to provide the professional services I am likely to need in order to give birth safely at home, and
- do you have the skill to recognise situations in which you would advise me to transfer to hospital, and
- do you have the wisdom to guide me?"
Yet planning VBAC at home may be considered by some to be unreasonable risk-taking. Midwives attending homebirths are required to comply with various guidelines that have been approved by the regulatory authority, such as the Safety and Quality Framework.[Open this link and scroll down to 'Eligible Midwives']. The Safety and Quality Framework seeks to ensure that women understand that the midwife has no professional indemnity insurance for homebirth, and requires a midwife providing homebirth services to
adhere to recognised consultation and referral guidelines developed by the Australian College of Midwives (ACM) and to have processes and relationships in place to demonstrate compliance with the guidelines.The ACM Guidelines list Casearean Section as
6.3 Previous Obstetric history
6.3.11 Caesarean Section
CODE B = CONSULT [Evaluation involving both primary and secondary care needs. The individual situation of the woman will be evaluated and agreements will be made about the responsibility (medical or midwifery) responsibility for maternity care]
The journey to homebirth for a midwife and woman, using the ACM Guidelines, may then proceed to Appendix A: WHEN A WOMAN CHOOSES CARE OUTSIDE THE RECOMMENDED ...
This process seeks to ensure that the midwife and other maternity professionals are advising the woman clearly, and the woman is making an informed decision.
If the midwife is Medicare-eligible, there are other requirements for collaborative arrangements before the midwife's fees can be rebated through Medicare. This is the case whether the plan is to give birth at home or hospital.
When planning VBAC in hospital, many of the same issues arise for women who intend to proceed without medical intervention, unless there is a valid reason. Most hospital guidelines require midwifery staff to obtain continuous electronic monitoring. The woman in this situation is able to decline, if she makes that decision.
A VBAC in hospital can proceed with continuous electronic fetal monitoring, epidural anaesthesia, IV fluids, a urinary catheter, forceps or other assistance that is available within the scope of a medically managed vaginal birth. Or a VBAC in hospital can proceed without any of these interventions.
Women planning VBAC in hospital would do well, if they can, to find a hospital that has a track record that demonstrates an understanding of VBAC. When you inquire about making a booking at the hospital, ask if the hospital has a clinical practice guideline or other written document that you can take away to read. Some hospitals have this material on the internet - click here for the Women's VBAC guideline. This will give you an idea of what you are likely to experience. Your midwife can help you understand the detail.
Specific questions can be asked of the hospital such as what is their current rate of planned vbac (out of all women who have had previous C/s surgery), and actual vbac. The denominator in the actual vbac rate is usually the number who planned vbac, or who commenced spontaneous labour. So if a hospital says "We have a 65% VBAC rate" it probably means that of all women with a previous C/S who intend to undergo a 'trial of scar' and commenced labour, 65% had vaginal births."
The decisions that need to be made in any pregnancy and labour (bac or not) are the same. Plan A. If mother and baby are well, and there is no valid reason to interfere with the natural process, the authentic midwife will act in a way that supports and protects natural physiological processes that lead to safe birth. This includes minimising any interruption or interference with the labouring woman.