Saturday, October 30, 2010

Singing group in Northcote for pregnant women



Ten Moons is a singing group for pregnant women. It provides a creative and safe space for women to come together and sing music that is all about feeling good. Experience some of the incredible health benefits that singing can offer during pregnancy and meet with other women in the community over song and a cup of tea.

For more information contact Gabby 0425 774 543 or email tenmoonsong@gmail.com

Friday, October 22, 2010

Medicare funding from 1 November 2010 ?

Some midwives and maternity consumers are waiting eagerly for the ability to claim Medicare payments for private midwifery services. A previous post gave the link to the Medicare fee schedule, and discussion on the required signed collaborative arrangement with one or more doctors that must be in place for a midwife to apply for a Medicare provider number.

To search for the legislative instruments go to the Commonwealth Government site.

This is a brief status update. With only a week until 1 November, we are wondering how it's progressing.

It appears that Medicare is ready to give midwives provider numbers and to rebate midwives' fees, AHPRA is not. It appears that AHPRA does not yet have a process up and running to proceed with applications for notation as an eligible midwife.

The optimists among us suppose that women will be able to back-claim from November 1 for Medicare. We will be interested to see what happens there.

We have been advised not to use the application form for notation as an eligible midwife on the AHPRA website as it needs to be amended – does not fit the criteria for eligibility. Will be re-loaded in a few weeks …


Remember the signed collaborative arrangement between an eligible midwife and one or more doctors, which is a mandated part of the provision of Medicare for midwifery services. Many midwives believe this law (Determination) denies the midwife's right to practise on her own authority, and potentially allows a doctor to veto the professional agreement between a midwife and a woman in her care. See the Australian Private Midwives Association (APMA) statement on the Collaborative Agreement.

Much more could be written, but it's Friday afternoon and my mind is tired. I hope this update is of use to some of our readers.


Midwives wishing to apply for a Medicare Provider Number can access information and forms at the Medicare website.

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Letters to public hospitals

Members of Midwives in Private Practice (MiPP) are sending letters on behalf of MiPP to public hospitals with maternity services, requesting a process that will enable midwives to achieve visiting access to provide private midwifery services for our clients in the hospital.

This is the pro-forma of the letter:

Director of Maternity Services
XXX Hospital

Dear XX
I am writing with reference to the recent health practitioner registration reforms, particularly in relation to eligible midwives being insured for the full scope of midwifery services including attending birth in hospital. The changes include the availability of government supported professional indemnity insurance for midwives, and being able to access Medicare provider numbers and limited prescribing and ordering of tests.

We understand that the reforms that impact on primary maternity services are intended to be consistent with the key principles developed by Australian Health Ministers Advisory Council (AHMAC 2008) “Primary Maternity Services in Australia – A Framework for Implementation. (Attachment 1). Midwives in private practice support each of these key principles, and look forward to being able to provide quality primary care for women who plan to give birth in hospital.

Members of Midwives in Private Practice (MiPP) and Australian Private Midwives Association are contacting all public hospitals to request details of how eligible midwives may proceed to apply for visiting access/clinical privileges. Would you please inform me of how your hospital is proceeding with implementation of the relevant changes, and the process for application and implementation of visiting access for midwives who are not employed by the hospital.

Yours sincerely


XXXX
On behalf of MiPP

ATTACHMENT 1

KEY PRINCIPLES
“Primary Maternity Services in Australia – A Framework for Implementation (AHMAC 2008)” articulated the following principles which underpin the range of models of maternity care available to women in Australia. These principles involve:
• ensuring services enable women to make informed and timely choices regarding their maternity care and to feel in control of their birthing experience

• ensuring that maternity services and care are provided in a culturally appropriate and responsive manner according to the individual needs of each woman

• maximising the potential of midwives, obstetricians, general practitioners and where appropriate other health professionals such as paediatricians and Aboriginal health workers specific knowledge, skills and attributes to provide a collaborative, coordinated multidisciplinary approach to maternity service delivery

• offering continuity of care, and wherever possible continuity of carer, as a key element of quality care

• ensuring that maternity services are of a high quality, safe, sustainable and provided within an environment of evidence ¬based best practice care

• ensuring continued access to best practice maternity services and care at the local level, while recognising that the benefits of local access must be considered within a quality and safety framework

• providing the right balance between primary level care and access to appropriate levels of medical expertise as clinically required

• working to reduce the health inequalities faced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mothers and babies and other disadvantaged populations.

Thursday, October 14, 2010

AIMS for a better birth

AIMS is the Association for Improvements in the Maternity Services.
AIMS has been at the forefront of the childbirth movement for more than forty years.

* Working towards normal birth
* Providing independent support and information about maternity choices
* Raising awareness of current research on childbirth and related issues

Although AIMS is based in the UK, many of the challenges in maternity services are the same in Australia, and globally.


excerpts from AIMS Informed Consent
An analysis of enquiries to the AIMS Helpline reveals that almost without exception women who intend to birth at home are given a long list of the ‘risks’ the staff perceive them to be taking. We have yet to hear from any woman who was also given a list of the risks of a hospital birth, so we have produced our own and suggest that this should be handed out to all women who intend delivering in hospital.

INFORMED CONSENT FOR GIVING BIRTH IN HOSPITAL

This Trust supports the view that women have choice and in order properly to exercise that choice they need to be fully informed of the risks in association with childbirth.
The following are the risks of a hospital delivery:

This hospital operates a shift system which means it is unlikely that you will be attended by the same midwife throughout your labour.

Because [the hospital is] short of staff you are unlikely to have the continuous support of a midwife as she will probably be trying to attend to at least two other women.

As this hospital has a 25% [to 30%] caesarean operation rate this means that you have at least a 1 in 4 chance of having a caesarean. Please be aware that this is major abdominal surgery that:
  • doubles the risks of maternal mortality,
  • increases the risk of damage to other internal organs and blood vessels,
  • carries a risk of infection, which may prolong a hospital stay,
  • interferes with the establishment of breastfeeding and
  • delays post operative recovery.

Research has also shown that this type of surgery:
  • produces harmful side effects according to which anaesthetic is used,
  • lowers fertility rates in women,
  • may increase the incidents of post natal depression,
  • adversely affects the baby because of the anaesthetic used,
  • can accidentally cut the baby as the incision is made,
  • produces babies who are less likely to breastfeed,
  • results in babies with breathing difficulties because they haven't received the benefits of being squeezed through the vaginal canal,
  • increases the risk of miscarriage in future pregnancies,
  • produces a greater risk of childhood asthma and
  • results in a greater risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome.

As the World Health Organisation has stated that there is no improvement to maternal or infant health when the caesarean operation rates exceeds 10% you should
understand that we are tr ying to reduce our caesarean rate.

...

You should understand that in this hospital, which is a high technology obstetric unit, only 1 in 6 women expecting their first baby and only 1 in 3 women expecting their subsequent babies will have a normal, straightforward, birth.

This hospital applies a time limit on the second stage of labour, this is not applied for your benefit it is imposed in order to ensure that you deliver as quickly as possible so that we can use your bed for another woman.

At this hospital the midwives will cut the cord as soon as the baby is delivered, this has adverse effects on the baby, but you need not worry we have resuscitation equipment at hand to help the baby breathe.

At this hospital the majority of women will give birth on their backs, despite the research indicating how this position increases the difficulty in pushing the baby out and causes trauma to both mother and baby.

This hospital prefers women to be quiet when they are in labour ... Therefore, in order to maintain a more subdued atmosphere, you will regularly be offered a range of opiate-based drugs ... Please be aware that this can lead to an increased chance of your child becoming a drug addict in later life and if administered at the wrong time during labour, will result in your baby being born in a dangerously stupefied state.

Do not worry, as the medical staff will inject the baby with an antidote as soon as it is born.

...

Source: AIMS JOURNAL VOL:19 NO:4 2007

Saturday, October 9, 2010

Medicare funding from 1 November 2010

The Health Insurance (Midwife and Nurse Practitioner) Determination 2010 has been released. To search for the legislative instruments click here.

We will keep our readers informed as soon as we hear of any progress by midwives in incorporating Medicare into their private practices.

There are widely different opinions held as to what the Medicare-Midwife will look like, what she will be required to do. Here is a section from the piece of regulation, the National Health (Collaborative arrangements for midwives) Determination 2010
...
5 Collaborative arrangements — general
(1) For the definition of authorised midwife in subsection 84 (1) of the Act, each of the following is a kind of collaborative arrangement for an eligible midwife:
(a) the midwife is employed or engaged by 1 or more obstetric specified medical practitioners, or by an entity that employs or engages 1 or more obstetric specified medical practitioners;
(b) a patient is referred, in writing, to the midwife for midwifery treatment by a specified medical practitioner;
(c) an agreement mentioned in section 6 for the midwife;
(d) an arrangement mentioned in section 7 for the midwife.

(2) For subsection (1), the arrangement must provide for:
(a) consultation between the midwife and an obstetric specified medical practitioner; and
(b) referral of a patient to a specified medical practitioner; and
(c) transfer of a patient’s care to an obstetric specified medical practitioner.

...

This is legislative language that confuses many.

The Medicare-Midwife (medi-wife) will:

* have a close working relationship with a group of obstetricians (no doctors work 24/7 these days)
* provide prenatal checks in the community, possibly in 'rooms' shared with obstetricians or other doctors (it has been suggested that a new GP Superclinic could include medi-wives)
* attend births in private hospitals where she has visiting access, and where the 'senior' member of the professional team is always the obstetrician
* be able to order basic tests and prescribe basic drugs, such as oxytocics
* provide postnatal services for mothers and babies in hospital, and possibly at home.

It is not yet clear whether public hospitals, which currently provide obstetric backup for the clients of privately practising midwives who plan homebirth, will accept the new medi-wife as a practitioner with visiting access.

Midwives are at present contacting public hospitals and requesting details of the hospitals' processes and time lines in preparation for enabling midwives to practise in the hospitals with visiting access.

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

PRINCIPLES underpinning maternity reform

Key Principles

“Primary Maternity Services in Australia – A Framework for Implementation (AHMAC 2008)” articulated the following principles which underpin the range of models of maternity care available to women in Australia.  These principles involve:
  • ensuring services enable women to make informed and timely choices regarding their maternity care and to feel in control of their birthing experience
  • ensuring that maternity services and care are provided in a culturally appropriate and responsive manner according to the individual needs of each woman
  • maximising the potential of midwives, obstetricians, general practitioners and where appropriate other health professionals such as paediatricians and Aboriginal health workers specific knowledge, skills and attributes to provide a collaborative, coordinated multidisciplinary approach to maternity service delivery
  • offering continuity of care, and wherever possible continuity of carer, as a key element of quality care
  • ensuring that maternity services are of a high quality, safe, sustainable and provided within an environment of evidence ­based best practice care
  • ensuring continued access to best practice maternity services and care at the local level, while recognising that the benefits of local access must be considered within a quality and safety framework
  • providing the right balance between primary level care and access to appropriate levels of medical expertise as clinically required
  • working to reduce the health inequalities faced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mothers and babies and other disadvantaged populations.
[This document is Attachment 1 to the draft Safety and Qualitiy Framework for private midwifery, a document which is currently being adopted by the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia]

Thursday, September 30, 2010

Dissenting voices from ACMQ

This message has been distributed widely, and is posted here with permission of Dr Jenny Gamble, representing the Queensland Branch of the Australian College of Midwives.

E Bulletin from ACMQ Executive Regarding the Medicare Determination:

The distribution last Wednesday of an e bulletin from the ACM national office concerning the Medicare determination has caused considerable confusion amongst members in Queensland and we believe does not present all of the options available to us.

ACMQ Executive acknowledges that the ACM National President and Board members are working hard on this issue and making some difficult decisions representing the colleges view at a national level. This E bulletin to members is in no way meant to be divisive or to detract from the work undertaken at national level. However, ACM national has concentrated on one option in the e-bulletin and we seek to provide an alternative for consideration by members.

In agreement with ACM national ACMQ Executive unreservedly supports Medicare for midwives, but the determination needs to be changed.

ACM Queensland Executive continues to have a bottom line position that we will not accept a “collaborative arrangement” with a medical practitioner that requires a signed agreement or provides an opportunity for a doctor to veto a midwives ability to access Medicare funding.

ACMQ Executive does not endorse the ‘keep silent, don’t rock the boat it’s too high risk’ position proposed by ACM national. .
ACMQ does not promote putting Medicare at risk.

...
ACMQ Executive believes that by using fear-based tactics the minister’s advisors have created panic that Medicare will not start and thereby hope to prevent midwives lobbying to change the determination. It is the opinion of the ACMQ Executive that pressure from the government on ACM National to cease lobbying to alter the medical veto over midwifery practice is a deliberate strategy to stop pressure to change the wording of the determination.

The Minister has the ability to change the determination any time. She clearly does not want to do so (and is possibly under pressure not to do so by the medical lobby) and will not do so unless midwives lobby.
...
ACMQ Executive offers the alternative position that we do not change our lobbying strategy. Members continue to ask for the wording in the determination to be altered. We recognise that in the immediate term it is unlikely that this will cause the Minister to change the wording. However early next year, with more evidence, it may become more obvious that there is a real difficulty in the currently worded determination.

ACMQ Executive is of the opinion that the strongest strategy is to indicate that we do not accept the current wording allowing a medical veto and that we stick together on this.

...
ACMQ Executive believes continuing to lobby to change the determination before a motion to disallow can even be introduced, let alone voted on, does not carry the level of risk outlined by the ACM national e-bulletin.

Timeline for the Determination:
• Determination was signed off by Governor General on 16 July which means that the Medicare for Midwives legislation is ready to commence on 1 November.
• Parliamentary process requires that because the determination is only signed off by Governor General, it is tabled in parliament in first six sitting days of the new parliament (28, 29, 30 Sept 2010, 26, 27, 28 October 2010).
• On the day it is tabled a new timeline commences in which a motion to disallow can be introduced within 15 sitting days. Therefore, if the determination is tabled on 28 Sept (the first day of the new parliament) the last possible day on which a motion to disallow can be introduced is the first sitting day of 2011 which is late Feb or early March. There is nothing ACM can do to alter these timeline as it is a fixed parliamentary process.
• On 1 November Medicare for midwives will commence.
...

ACMQ Executive maintains the line that the determination is unacceptable, that we continue to lobby that it is unacceptable and that we demand a meeting with the Minister (not only her advisors).
...
All midwives who experience difficulty accessing Medicare due to an inability to obtain a signed medical agreement have the opportunity to keep the pressure on by notifying ACM national, ACMQ and the Minister’s office of the practical difficulties created by the determination.

If it turns out that the determination is working well and women have no difficulty accessing Medicare funded midwifery care this will soon become apparent. If this is the situation then any motion to disallow can be withdrawn as stated earlier.

ACMQ’s position involves lobbying to change the determination and buying time to see if the determination will or won’t work.

ACMQ Executive holds the view that a frank and fulsome communication between all members is required to ensure that a representative view can be tabled if the situation occurs that the determination will be voted on in the Senate/House of Representatives.

Before sending this communication we have considered all aspects of this complicated situation in detail. Thank you for considering this alternative option, it is now completely up to you as a member to decide if you would like to write to/contact your MP, the Minister, Jenny Gamble as our National Delegate and ACM National to lobby for the wording of the determination to be changed.

ACMQ Executive will continue to apply pressure and lobby to get the determination changed.


This e-bulletin is supported unanimously by the ACMQ Executive:
Hazel Brittain - President
Jodi Bunn – Executive Member
Jenny Gamble – National Delegate
Richard Hayes - Treasurer
Bec Jenkinson - Consumer
Marie McAuliffe – Executive Member
Mandy Ostrenski – Executive Member
Sue Rath – Executive Member
Mary Sidebotham – Vice President
Barb Soong – Executive Member
Teresa Walsh - Secretary
Kellie Wilton - Student